Highlight topics update July 2025
In 2024, NERC undertook an evaluation of its highlight topics (HTs) scheme, following ten rounds of funding. The evaluation aimed to understand the scheme’s effectiveness, agility and bureaucratic burden and explore opportunities for improvements in all these areas. Here is a summary of the key findings, conclusions, and next steps.
What we learned
The evaluation generated a number of insights. This included:
- the HTs scheme was valued for enabling large-scale, complex projects, though the smaller £2.5 million award level was sometimes too limiting
- it successfully drew in high-quality ideas in novel areas or research gaps
- the scheme enabled community-driven research, and provided an opportunity to develop ideas via stakeholder collaboration
- HT idea submissions tended to come from a small proportion of the research community, with non-higher education institution stakeholders often under-represented
- the HT idea generation process and timing of opportunity announcement were perceived as potentially introducing bias in funding outcomes
- there was a perception of a lack of transparency around prioritisation and selection of HT ideas, with limited feedback to submitters
- the HT idea generation and prioritisation process was lengthy and administratively burdensome
Based on these insights, NERC drew the following conclusions:
- NERC should maintain the challenge- and outcome-focused approach of HTs and retain an opportunity that offers this scale of funding for standalone projects
- there is value in using community-informed evidence when identifying NERC’s strategic research investment priorities
- diversity of engagement across the breadth of the research and stakeholder community in informing priority research areas could be improved
- the process for identifying priorities for research investment should be more streamlined and decision-making more transparent
Additional considerations:
- funding offered via the existing HTs and discovery science large grants schemes is very similar in scale and purpose
- there are opportunities to avoid duplication, add value and reduce community burden by harmonising aspects of these two schemes
What this means for the future
We are evolving our funding approach to respond to community feedback and simplify our processes. We will launch a single new scheme to replace our existing large grants and highlight topics, with funding offered on a similar monetary scale.
This new scheme will support a combination of discovery science and strategically targeted research within the same funding opportunity. Applicants will decide which aspect they wish to address within their application. Strategic priority areas will be identified within each funding opportunity. Funding will be allocated based primarily on research quality, but with an expectation that a certain proportion will be directed towards projects in strategic priority areas.
Creating this new scheme enables review and harmonisation of processes and funding mechanisms across two very similar funding streams and provides an opportunity to review our process for identifying priority areas for investment. We intend to launch a pilot of this new scheme in 2027.
Bridging the gap
To maintain support for large-scale, curiosity-driven research in the interim, NERC will launch a discovery science large grants funding opportunity in October 2025 with an uplifted budget of £20 million.
NERC values information received directly from the community regarding larger scale, including interdisciplinary, challenges that require substantial environmental research to be addressed. We therefore encourage all relevant stakeholders to continue to provide this input via existing communication channels. This will contribute to the evidence base used to inform future strategic priority areas.
More details on how the new scheme will be delivered will be shared in due course.